Mexborough & Swinton Times – Saturday 25 April 1914
The Cost of the Yorkshire Miners’ Strike
An Estimated Loss of £5,000,000
The Yorkshire miners having now resumed work, it is possible to estimate with fair accuracy (says the “Yorkshire Post”) the cost of the minimum wage strike to the miners, to the coalowners, and to the trade of Yorkshire. The complete county strike has extended over a period of three weeks, less the period of one or two days which would have been observed as holidays, while the stoppage in the South Yorkshire district, at the pits particularly affected by the dispute, continued for ten weeks.
It is probably within the mark to say that the complete cost of the dispute, in the loss of coal production, of profits to owners, of wages to workmen, and in strike pay to the Yorkshire Miners’ Association, has been £5,000,000. The larger part of the loss to the coalowners means that the production has been delayed, the coal remains to be won, and the profit to be made. The coalowners stand to recoup themselves of their loss by the higher prices obtained for coal (other than that sold on contract) during the stoppage, and the clearance of stocks at a time when trade was rising and selling prices were falling. The loss to the men is in the main irrecoverable. They have had in South Yorkshire ten weeks enforced idleness, and at the other pits in the county three weeks’ “holiday,” for which they have received strike pay at 9s. per week in lieu of their ordinary earnings. The loss in wages for the county strike may be estimated at £500,000, and in the more protracted struggle in South Yorkshire at £200,000. The Yorkshire Miners’ Association has paid out in strike pay a sum approaching £150,000, practically exhausting the reserves created since the minimum wage stoppage of two years ago.
The question which the men may well ask themselves is: What have we to show in the way of gain for the outlay on the county strike? It must be admitted that not a single concession has been obtained as a result of forcing the county strike. The important concession of the addition of the percentages of advance given by the Conciliation Board to the minima fixed by the district chairman had already been obtained when the decision of the Yorkshire Miners’ Council not to suspend the strike notice was made.
The final terms of settlement practically provide for the surrender of the advance of 6d. per day given by Sir Edward Clarke at those pits where the conditions of economic production are unfavourable. There we have the recognition of a principle which is outside the scope of the Minimum Wage Act—the economic position of individual pits as a factor governing wages. In the broader sense the factor is already recognised in the widely different wage rates paid in districts like Somerset, Bristol, and the Forest of Dean, as compared with Yorkshire, Lancashire, Nottinghamshire, and Derbyshire. The economic conditions compelled the recognition of that factor in the Minimum Wage Act in reference to districts. In the Yorkshire settlement the economic factor is now definitely recognised as between individual collieries in the same district, and it is admitted, as a principle, that the same wage is not possible in old pits approaching the stage of exhaustion in South Yorkshire as can be paid in the new pits of the Doncaster district. Thus the strike has brought into full force economic conditions which are more powerful even than legislation.
From the men’s point of view the barren results of a strike which has cost them one million sterling form an object lesson against the “sympathetic” strike.
Sir Joseph Walton and the Strike
Sir Joseph Walton, Bart., M.P., speaking at Barnsley, said he deeply regretted the recent coal strike, for it had been a bad business both for masters and men. The masters must have suffered enormous loss, and during the last few weeks perhaps a million sterling in wages had not entered the homes of Yorkshire owing to the stoppage. Furthermore, £180,000 had been spent from the accumulated funds of the Miners’ Association. He had been glad to hear of the settlement, and he hoped it would be a very long time before there would be a similar stoppage.