Home Industry and Commerce Mining A Yorkshire Coal Strike – Threatened Blow Falls All Pits Shut Down

A Yorkshire Coal Strike – Threatened Blow Falls All Pits Shut Down

April 1914

Mexborough & Swinton Times – Saturday 4 April 1914

A Yorkshire Coal Strike

Threatened Blow Falls

All Pits Shut Down

Grave Situation

When everyone was settling down to the anticipation of a comfortable settlement of the Yorkshire coal dispute as a result of the deliberations of the Joint Committee appointed by the Coal Conciliation Board to deal with the matters in controversy, the Yorkshire Miners’ Association last Saturday provided a bombshell in the shape of a resolution authorising the miners to act upon their notices handed in a fortnight ago and leave work as they expire.

Very few people anticipated that the minimum wage trouble which has brought about this crisis would develop into anything more serious than a mere demonstration. It will be remembered that the Joint Committee arrived at the nucleus of a settlement before adjourning the conference for a week. The owners agreed to approach the general question of conceding the men’s interpretation of the latest award of the South Yorkshire Minimum Wage Board, on condition that the notices then current were suspended, and the men continued at work pending a final settlement. They also agreed that whatever was due to the men should be paid as from the date of the award, which meant that all arrears would be paid.

A Plain Issue

It was rather surprising and very much to be regretted that a settlement could not then have been agreed upon. We are told that unforeseen difficulties presented them during the conference, but it is difficult to imagine what they could be. The issue, so far as it was known here in South Yorkshire, was a perfectly plain one, and the question for argument was as to whether the owners’ or the miners’ interpretation of the award was the fair and reasonable one, and it might have been supposed that even in the event of failure to agree on this head, nothing would be easier than for Sir Edward Clarke to be called upon to clarify the situation by making more explicit the intention of the award.

To the lay mind the miners are unquestionably in the right, for it could scarcely have been the intention of the Minimum Wage Board to take no cognisance of the fifteen per cent. advance awarded by the Conciliation Board in the interval between the first and second awards of the Minimum Wage Board. Obviously, the Minimum Wage Board meant their extra sixpence a day to supplement and not to override the seven-pence-halfpenny granted by the Conciliation Board.

Situation Bungled

It is particularly exasperating to see the situation bungled so badly as it apparently has been. The whole imbroglio is a perfectly gratuitous one. Most of the owners are prepared to pay the full minimum, that is the 1/1½ advance upon the minimum wage of 1912, making a total of 7/10½ a day for colliers, and 7/9 for fillers. Many pits, particularly in the new Doncaster area, are almost entirely unaffected by the dispute. They have so few claims for the minimum wage, and the average wage is well above the total demanded by the miners, that it is not worth their while to hold out against what most of them admit to be a just demand.

Thousands of miners in Yorkshire, the proportion is estimated by a reliable authority at three-fifths, have ceased work this week to enforce a demand for something like sixpence a day less than they are actually receiving. That is to say these miners are in no case earning less than 8s. 3d. to 8s. 6d. per day. Nevertheless, their position is a perfectly consistent and logical one. They are fighting for a principle. Although many individual coalowners in South Yorkshire are paying and are willing to pay, more than the total minimum demanded, as a corporate body the best they have offered so far is the payment of the original minimum, and the fifteen per cent. advance of 7s. 4½d. per day.

Miners Lose Patience

The miners are fighting against the suggested setting aside of the new award, and by an overwhelming majority on Saturday they forced the Yorkshire Miners’ Association to declare war, against the advice of Mr. John Wadsworth, M.P., and Mr. Hoskins, the South Yorkshire representatives on the Joint Committee, who were in favour of the suspension of notices until it could be definitely ascertained either that the owners were willing to concede the full demand, or that there was no prospect of their doing so.

An Anomaly

The position in Rotherham, where this unrest had its genesis, is a curious one. The five Rotherham pits which broke ground, have now been idle for six weeks, despite the fact that since hostilities commenced certain of the owners have offered to concede the demands of the men. The men could not avail themselves of the offer because the grievance had become a County grievance, and the terms had to be obtained for the whole County. At the beginning of March notices were posted at the affected pits in the Rotherham district to the following effect:

“It is intended to pay at this colliery the new minimum, subject to the resolutions of the Conciliation Board dated October 21, 1912, January 6, 1913, and April 15, 1913. The collier who does not earn the minimum wage will therefore be paid 7s. 3d. plus the additions to the 1888 rate provided for by those resolutions. It is also intended to pay, on the first day after the resumption of work, to colliers entitled thereto, the arrears for the weeks ending 11th and 18th February, thus bringing the arrears to date.”

The anomaly that appears to be created is that where the workman earns the actual minimum of 7s. 3d. per day, the percentage increases are not to be added or paid by the employers, and it is here where the root of the trouble occurs. For instance, if a man earned 7s. 3d. or any larger wage, that is all the employer would pay, but if he earned 7s. 2d. then the employer would have to pay 7s. 10½d., the minimum plus the three percentages of the 5 per cent. It is obvious that the coal-getters who earned 7s. 3d. and received that wage, while another man who earned 7s. received 7s. 10½d., would in future weeks when his earnings were on the border line of the average, take care to see that they fell below rather than above the minima fixed by the district chairman.

Prospects of the Fight

As to the actual prospects of the strike, it is difficult to say which way the matter will go. The miners have on the whole the greater proportion of sympathy. They have in the main, a righteous cause, but they are, nevertheless, playing a hazardous game. The very fact that the whole of West Yorkshire while agreeing to strike, is actually unaffected by the wages dispute, being regulated by another Minimum Wage Board whose award is being adhered to, and also the fact that a large proportion of the South Yorkshire miners are not affected, in that they are earning more than the minima demanded, is in itself a danger. Three-fifths of the miners are striking sympathetically, and the sympathetic strike is not only a mistake, but a source of weakness. The lack of the common cause is an embryonic weakness.

The owners have a right to assume that in an extended struggle the self-interest of those miners who have nothing to support them but a spirit of camaraderie, will operate in the owners’ favour. Then again, a County strike cannot be a tithe as effective as a national strike. We have had a very bitter experience of the frightful waste and suffering which a county strike is capable of inflicting. One would have thought the calamity of 1893 was too fresh in the minds of the older and more seasoned colliers to induce them light-heartedly to enter a struggle in which the owners have all the best of the conditions. For the South Yorkshire pits can ride out of the storm if their trade is being temporarily dealt with elsewhere, while the miner has only his strike pay to keep him going. It is true that the Yorkshire Miners’ Association is so far recovered from the national strike of 1912 as to be worth about £240,000, a circumstance about which the President some time ago at Moorthorpe somewhat indiscreetly boasted, but there are 120,000 members to be supported out of it, and a fund like that would vanish in a long struggle like dew before the morning sun.

It is understood that further efforts will be made to-day to arrive at a settlement by the Joint Committee.

170,000 Men Affected

The following is a table showing approximately the number of men who have left work as the notices have fallen in:

Day Number of Men Idle
Monday 35,000
Tuesday 75,000
Wednesday 120,000
Thursday 170,000
If dispute lasts more than a week 250,000

Mexboro’ District at a Standstill

That the miners are indeed in deadly earnest in resisting the owners’ interpretation of the Minimum Wage Award was brought home to us on Wednesday, when every pit in the county came to a standstill. On Tuesday, as their notices fell in, the men at Cortonwood and Thrybergh Hall and Warren Vale left work, and on Wednesday afternoon, by four o’clock or so, the last ton of coal had been drawn, and the owners proceeded to shut up shop pending the issue of the struggle.

The nine pits which may be described as being in the Mexboro’ district employ, all told, some 25,000 men and boys, about a fourth of whom are nominally affected by the dispute. Of those to whom the quarrel is germane a very large proportion have no monetary interest in it, because they are earning some shillings a day more than the minimum demanded.

At Cortonwood the average earnings are four shillings more, and at Denaby and Cadeby the average earnings for the last month of the miners were 12s. 10d., or five shillings more. It does not follow, of course, that there are no miners working under the minimum, but we understand authoritatively that at Cortonwood no claim has been made for the minimum for some months, and that at Denaby and Cadeby, where the wage bill is between £7,000 and £8,000 per week, while the claims for the minimum amount to an average of £5 per week. The same state of things applies generally to all the pits in this district, and on the face of it there appears no justification for a minimum wage strike. But, in explanation of the scarcity of claims for the minimum, three possibilities are suggested. The first is the humbug and delay and other complications involved in the minimum; and the second the fear of being victimised. The third is peculiar to the Denaby and Cadeby mines. There it is suggested that, where a man is earning a little under the minimum occasionally, he would be out of pocket by claiming the minimum, because it would disentitle him to a share of the bonus fund which has been established by the Company for distribution every quarter, and which is based on a five per cent. increase. Therefore, again, it is suggested, only those who are habitually coming home under the regulation six and ninepence a day are claiming, and these claims in the aggregate amount to five pounds per week.

Wombwell Hard Hit

The strike has commenced at last, and here at Wombwell find ourselves as hard hit as any district in this busy Dearne Valley. As the working weeks concluded according to the different systems in vogue, pit after pit had closed down automatically, until all the great organs of industry, whose grimy throats have sent forth incessantly, day after day, for the past two years countless tons of the very elixir of commerce, have been laid low indefinitely. An uncanny stillness broods over all. Still it is not good to be pessimistic, and though there is a distinct presentiment abroad that the struggle will be an unusually long one, we hope for the best.

Colonel T. W. M. Mitchell hit off the feeling of all in the course of a speech at the opening of a bazaar at the Wesleyan Chapel on Wednesday, when he said that though times were not as propitious as they might be he hoped the cloud which had come over them would not be long in passing, and that those at the head of affairs who had the matter in hand would be able to bring about a speedy settlement.

Denaby Miners Come Out

The Denaby miners came out on strike on Wednesday, and at a meeting held at the Reresby Arms on the previous night, a resolution expressing the branch’s support of the action of the executive was passed. The men left work at the expiration of the fortnight’s notice, but a number of miners, who omitted to give notice until the latter part of last week, were enabled to discontinue work by the indulgence of the management. Steps are being taken to secure the employment of Union miners, so far as is practicable, in the performance of work essential to the safety of the mine.

Pits to Be Kept in Repair

So far there is nothing sinister or unpleasant in the atmosphere. The strike is too fresh for that. The management of the various mines has up to now preserved an excellent understanding with the men, whose attitude towards the question of maintaining and repairing the mines is a sane and sensible one. At most of the pits this work will be done by the permanent staff, but in the larger mines, and especially where the roads are tender, some of the strikers will be incorporated by consent of their Union. This is particularly the case at Denaby and Cadeby, where a list of men who are prepared to do this work has been got out, and some hundred or so at each colliery will be employed, so that the pits will be ready for working so soon as a settlement has been declared. These men will be placed under subscription to contribute at the rate of threepence per day towards the maintenance of those members of the Union who are out of work. That is the condition upon which they will be allowed to work, and, of course, they will receive no strike pay. The payment of strike pay begins a week after the termination of work.

Mineral Trains Cancelled

Already local trade is beginning to suffer the devastating consequences inseparable from a coal strike. The railway traffic, an immediate and unfailing index to the state of trade generally, is slackening. By Wednesday as many as sixty mineral trains had been cancelled. Evidently the coalowners have made good use of the time at their disposal, for there are practically no reserve supplies, and the sidings at every colliery will soon be clear. All the coal in sight is being swept up as rapidly as possible.

Federation Meeting Next Week

Mr. J. Wadsworth, M.P., general secretary of the Yorkshire Miners’ Association, stated on Tuesday that it is probable a meeting of the Miners’ Federation will be held next week to consider the Yorkshire question.

Feeding the Children

Distribution at Piccadilly

On Friday, the Piccadilly Committee met and distributed the first portion of bread to the children, whose parents are on strike. There were 38 children, and each child received a loaf of bread.

On Monday, the committee met in the Primitive Methodist Chapel, and, after discussion, it was decided to distribute bread out again on Tuesday, when the 38 children received a large loaf of bread.

On Tuesday morning the host and hostess of the High House, Piccadilly, Mr. and Mrs. George Macbon, gave to each child whose parents are on strike a bun and coffee before going to school.